I periodically write reviews of some of my kid’s favorite stories in book or movie form (you can check out my take on Miss Rumphius here). Room on the Broom is a favorite of all three older kids, so it kind of begged to have its own review…
I was first introduced to the delight that is Magic Light one Saturday morning while my children were choosing a show to watch on Netflix. Nadia spotted a gruff-looking creature with purple prickles all over its back in the lower corner, and immediately asked if we could watch the monster one. I knew that The Gruffalo was probably good, somewhere deep in the recesses of my mind (I think I’d read it at a bookstore once for fun in my teens?) and so we clicked through and tried it out. I was blown away.
If there’s one thing consistent about very young children’s programming, it’s that most of it is grade-A crap. You have to sift through bucketloads of mindless, unimaginative drivel to get one decent show. And the excellent ones are truly few and far between. These are the ones that combine curiosity, gentleness, great art, and well-written story into something I want my children to see — and something that I enjoy watching as well.
I say I was blown away by Magic Light in general, rather than by The Gruffalo in particular, because shortly after enjoying The Gruffalo we discovered their other offerings available on Netflix — The Gruffalo’s Child, Room on the Broom, and Stick Man. All of these come recommended for compelling stories, interesting animation and scores, and child-like pacing. One of my favorite things about them is that they are faithful to the author’s intent, while gently expanding the story ideas in the source material for the better. But the one that all of my kid’s pick again and again is Room on the Broom.
the importance of character
Room on the Broom begins by establishing the relationship between the witch and the cat. The witch is a joyful, empathetic type (if a bit clumsy) and very kind toward everyone she meets, perhaps to a fault. The cat, on the other hand, is not so much unkind as possessive. He feels it is his duty to protect the witch and her best interests. He doesn’t want anyone taking advantage of her kindness, or (on a deeper level) getting in the way of their special friendship. In his mind, there is room on the broom for one and only one: him.
You may wonder how I know so much about these characters. It’s because Magic Light goes out of their way to translate the 2D characters from the book into 3D characterizations in simple and subtle ways, through both expression and action. When ants begin carrying the witch’s potion ingredients off, the cat anxiously brushes them away. But the witch stops him with a smile, then drops a single leaf into each ant’s waiting jaws. The cat, in response, rolls his eyes.
This interaction is seconds long, but establishes key ingredients of each of their character’s personalities. And every character from here on out receives the same treatment, with later actions reinforcing every character’s moment in the spotlight. I can’t help but admire the careful, clever handling of the characters. And you know what? My kids get these nuances, because kids are sharp and they pick up more than we give them credit for.
Side note: every time I watch this thing, and it has been many times, there’s something new I notice about the characters or the background. Like the moment when the dog’s flapping tongue hits the cat in the cheek, or how the witch finds the snake from the Gruffalo story hiding in a woodpile. All children’s programming should be this detailed and intentional.
establishing conflict
Then the witch (as she is wont to do) loses her hat. The primary conflict appears when an overly-enthusiastic dog finds it and brings it back. The cat is obviously not a fan of sharing space or friendship, and unequivocally rejects the dog. But the witch is too kind, and offers the dog space on the broom.
As they travel along, the witch invites more characters onto the broom and the cat becomes more angry with them all. It’s a very personal conflict for me as an introvert. I value my close friends dearly, and sharing them with others is not easy for me. The more people we add to the equation, the worse the situation.
And yet, in short order, the group adds a melancholic green bird and a neat-freak frog. The witch is consistently kind toward all of these outcasts and builds a little family of her own as a result. Of course, her cat becomes more and more frustrated. He sees what’s coming and knows that all this kindness will eventually cause disaster. And finally, what he has predicted all along happens, and the broom snaps in two. The weight of the witch’s kind decisions has finally broken her ability to support this odd little family.
But that’s not the end of their troubles.
use of growing tension
Unbeknownst to the group, they have been tracked from the beginning of the story by a witch-eating dragon. Of course, we know the beast is coming, because the creators dropped hint after hint of the impending dragon attack from the very beginning.
This was the icing on the cake for my kids (3, 4, and 6, respectively). The moment they saw the dragon’s yellow eyes open in the shadows at the very beginning, they were hooked. They knew the dragon was coming, and every time it showed up it got closer and fiercer to a yummy witch meal. This is the type of tension and danger that we all crave.
The brilliance of Magic Light’s choice to do this is that in the midst of drawing us into caring for the characters, they take time to ratchet up the danger these characters are in, and it pulls us deeper into the story. The stakes are high here. Not only might the cat blow a blood vessel, the witch we all know and love might get eaten by a dragon.
the payoff
At the height of the story, all hope is lost. The cat and the other recipients of the witch’s kindness have all been unceremoniously dropped into a muddy bog. The cat is at his wit’s end, and clearly indicates to the others that all of this is their fault. And then the hungry dragon catches their beloved witch.
Despite the absence of a side of fries, the dragon settles down to a witchy feast. And that’s when every story element that’s been built-up before pays off in spades. The cat and all the others are brought together by their shared care for the witch to defeat the dragon. The sum of their distinct personalities, when directed by love, is truly greater than the parts.
There’s only one problem left to solve. The broom is broken, and there’s only room for the witch and the cat. What is to be done? I won’t spoil it for you, but it is such a satisfying ending that you absolutely must watch it. Since when do I worry about spoiling a kid’s movie? When it makes me cry every time, that’s when.
so why do we love it?
When I asked my kids to share why they love this film, they gave me various reasons. The witch is pretty. The dragon is scary. The cat learns his lesson. But Nadia summed it up: “How beautifully they flew!”
When creators pay attention to craft, character, and whimsy, they create something wondrous that will stick in a child’s mind. Sure, Room on the Broom has great lessons for kids about kindness, sacrifice, and friendship. But my kids will remember it because those things were presented as not only true, but beautiful and important.